You believe you have dealt with your tax liability, but HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) says the amount is still outstanding.
Perhaps a bank payment has not appeared on your tax account. Maybe a payment has been allocated to the wrong accounting period. Or HMRC has rejected a proposed arrangement that you believed would settle the debt.
These situations can be worrying, especially where interest is accumulating or a business is already experiencing cash flow difficulties.
However, the appropriate response depends on why HMRC has not recognised the payment or arrangement.
A missing bank transfer is different from a rejected payment method. Both are different from a formal disagreement about how much tax is legally owed.
This guide explains how to identify the problem, gather evidence, contact HMRC, explore payment arrangements and understand when a statutory review or appeal may be available.
Why Might HMRC Reject or Fail to Recognise a Tax Payment?
Not every apparent payment rejection involves a legal dispute.
Some problems are administrative and can be resolved by tracing a transaction or correcting a payment reference.
Others involve a substantive disagreement about whether a proposed payment method is legally effective.
The most common situations fall into four categories.
1. A payment has not appeared on the tax account
A taxpayer may have authorised a bank transfer or card payment, but the amount has not yet appeared against the relevant liability.
Possible explanations include processing delays, incorrect payment details, an unsuccessful transaction or an allocation problem.
The first step is to establish whether the payment was actually completed.
2. The payment was allocated to the wrong liability
A business may use an incorrect tax reference or a reference relating to an earlier accounting period.
For Corporation Tax, the payment reference generally contains 17 characters and changes between accounting periods.
HMRC explains that using the wrong reference can delay a payment or result in it being applied to another tax bill.
Where this happens, the business can contact HMRC to request that the payment be moved.
See HMRC’s Corporation Tax payment guidance.
3. HMRC does not accept the proposed payment method
A taxpayer may attempt to settle a liability using a document, instrument or arrangement that HMRC does not recognise as payment.
For example, HMRC has expressly stated that it does not accept privately created bills of exchange or similar instruments as payment of tax liabilities.
Sending such a document does not, by itself, discharge the debt.
Where a proposed method is rejected, the taxpayer should establish whether the liability remains outstanding and arrange a legally effective payment.
4. HMRC disagrees with the amount of tax owed
Sometimes the issue is not payment processing at all.
HMRC may have issued an assessment, amended a return, refused a relief or imposed a penalty.
In those circumstances, the taxpayer may need to consider the applicable statutory review or appeal procedures.
These distinctions are important because each problem requires a different response.
Step 1: Identify Exactly What HMRC Is Disputing
Before sending further correspondence or making another payment, identify the nature of the disagreement.
Ask:
- Does HMRC say no payment was received?
- Has a payment been received but allocated incorrectly?
- Has HMRC rejected the proposed method of settlement?
- Is HMRC disputing the tax calculation itself?
- Has HMRC issued a formal assessment, penalty or appealable decision?
Review the relevant tax account, payment records and correspondence.
A clear description of the problem helps determine whether it should be addressed through payment enquiries, debt management, a formal appeal or another procedure.
For example, a company that paid £12,000 using the wrong Corporation Tax reference will usually need an allocation enquiry.
A company challenging a Corporation Tax assessment may need to follow the appeal procedure described in HMRC’s decision letter.
Treating both situations as the same kind of dispute can cause unnecessary delays.
Step 2: Check Whether the Payment Was Successfully Processed
If the problem concerns a bank transfer, begin with the bank or payment provider.
Confirm the amount, date, payment reference and destination account.
Check whether the transaction was completed, returned or rejected.
Next, compare those details with HMRC’s published instructions for the relevant tax.
For Corporation Tax, HMRC provides information about bank transfers, online payments, Direct Debit and other accepted methods.
Processing times differ.
For example, Faster Payments will usually reach HMRC on the same or following day, while Bacs payments generally take three working days.
See HMRC’s Corporation Tax bank transfer guidance.
If the payment was successfully completed but is not reflected correctly on the tax account, contact HMRC with the transaction details.
Keep copies of all relevant evidence.
Step 3: Establish Whether the Tax Liability Remains Outstanding
A taxpayer should not assume that a liability has been discharged merely because correspondence was sent or a payment instruction was initiated.
The question is whether the relevant legal requirements for payment or another effective discharge have been satisfied.
Consider a hypothetical company with an outstanding Corporation Tax liability of £45,000.
The company sends HMRC a written proposal offering to settle the amount through an alternative financial instrument.
HMRC subsequently confirms that it does not accept the proposed method.
The company’s records show that the document was delivered, but no recognised payment was made.
In that situation, proof of delivery does not establish that the £45,000 liability was discharged.
The company should establish the amount currently due, including any applicable interest or penalties, and consider its available payment options.
If the company disputes the underlying legal position, it should obtain appropriately qualified advice. It should not assume that sending further copies of the same document suspends the debt.
Step 4: Contact the Correct HMRC Department
The appropriate contact route depends on the tax and the issue.
For example, Corporation Tax payment enquiries should be directed to the relevant Corporation Tax contact service.
A business experiencing difficulty paying its tax may need HMRC’s payment support arrangements.
A taxpayer challenging an assessment should generally follow the instructions in the decision letter.
When contacting HMRC, have the following information available:
- Your name or registered company name.
- The relevant tax reference.
- The accounting period or tax year.
- The amount HMRC says is outstanding.
- Payment dates and transaction references.
- Copies of relevant correspondence.
- A clear explanation of the outcome you are requesting.
Keep a record of when you contacted HMRC, what information was provided and any response received.
Where a matter is financially significant or legally disputed, written confirmation can be particularly valuable.
Step 5: Understand Whether Interest or Penalties May Apply
An unresolved tax liability can have financial consequences.
Depending on the tax, the amount outstanding and the circumstances, HMRC may charge late payment interest or penalties.
These are not necessarily the same thing.
Interest generally reflects the period during which tax remains unpaid under the applicable rules.
Penalties depend on the relevant statutory provisions and circumstances.
A business should therefore establish whether HMRC is seeking:
- The original tax liability.
- Late payment interest.
- A penalty.
- Other recoverable amounts.
This distinction matters because the available challenge procedures may differ.
For example, a taxpayer may disagree with a penalty but still owe the underlying tax.
Likewise, successfully challenging a penalty does not automatically remove an outstanding tax liability.
Step 6: Consider a Time to Pay Arrangement
If the tax is genuinely owed but the taxpayer cannot pay it in full, a payment arrangement may be available.
HMRC operates a system commonly known as Time to Pay, which can allow eligible taxpayers to settle outstanding tax through instalments.
An arrangement is not automatic.
HMRC assesses the taxpayer’s circumstances and whether the proposed payments are realistic.
For businesses, HMRC may request information about income, expenditure, available assets and the company’s ability to meet future obligations.
A company should be prepared to explain:
- How much it currently owes.
- Why it cannot pay in full.
- How much it can pay immediately.
- What it can realistically pay each month.
- How it intends to remain compliant with future tax obligations.
HMRC may expect businesses to consider ways of reducing their debts, including the use of available assets.
An agreed payment arrangement does not necessarily eliminate interest.
See HMRC’s guidance on setting up a tax payment plan.
Example: A business facing temporary cash flow pressure
A company owes £30,000 in Corporation Tax.
A major customer has delayed payment, leaving the business unable to settle the entire amount immediately.
The company prepares a cash flow forecast showing what it can pay now and what it expects to receive over the next few months.
It contacts HMRC, explains the circumstances and proposes an affordable repayment schedule.
HMRC will assess the proposal before deciding whether to agree to an arrangement.
The company should not treat the proposal as approved until HMRC confirms the arrangement.
Step 7: Determine Whether You Have a Right to Appeal
Not every disagreement with HMRC creates an automatic right of appeal.
Statutory appeal rights generally relate to specified decisions, assessments and penalties.
Where HMRC has issued a formal decision, the letter should explain the available procedure.
For many tax decisions, the deadline to appeal or accept a review is usually 30 days.
However, the precise route and deadline depend on the tax and decision involved.
For direct taxes such as Corporation Tax and Income Tax, the taxpayer will generally need to appeal to HMRC first.
For certain indirect tax decisions, including VAT decisions, HMRC may offer a statutory review or the option of appealing to the tribunal.
See HMRC’s guidance on disagreeing with a tax decision.
What should an appeal contain?
The requirements depend on the decision, but relevant information may include:
- The decision being challenged.
- The taxpayer’s identifying details.
- The reasons for disagreement.
- Supporting evidence.
- The figures or treatment the taxpayer believes are correct.
An appeal should address the legal or factual basis of the decision.
Simply stating that HMRC is wrong, without explaining why, may not be sufficient.
Step 8: Understand the Difference Between an HMRC Review and a Tribunal Appeal
A statutory review allows an HMRC officer who was not involved in the original decision to reconsider it.
The review officer may uphold, vary or cancel the decision.
HMRC states that reviews usually take around 45 days, although some cases take longer.
If the taxpayer remains dissatisfied after the review, an appeal to the tax tribunal may be available, subject to the relevant rules and deadlines.
A tribunal appeal is a formal legal process.
The tribunal considers the evidence, applicable legislation and legal arguments.
For complex or high-value disputes, professional advice can help the taxpayer understand the merits, risks, costs and procedural requirements.
See HMRC’s statutory review guidance.
Does Appealing Mean You Can Stop Paying?
Not necessarily.
The payment position during a dispute depends on the type of tax, the decision and whether postponement or another form of relief is available.
For certain direct tax disputes, a taxpayer may request postponement of the disputed amount.
HMRC must consider the request under the relevant rules.
For indirect tax disputes, different rules apply, including provisions concerning payment and financial hardship.
Interest may continue to accrue on amounts ultimately found to be payable.
Businesses should therefore avoid assuming that lodging an appeal automatically suspends every payment obligation.
HMRC explains the different arrangements in its guidance on delaying payment during appeals and reviews.
What Happens if HMRC Rejects an Alternative Tax Settlement Method?
Alternative settlement proposals require particular care.
A document may be legally recognised for one commercial purpose without being accepted as a method of paying a UK tax liability.
For example, the Bills of Exchange Act 1882 provides a legal framework for bills of exchange.
However, HMRC states that it does not accept bills of exchange or similar private instruments as payment of tax liabilities.
The existence of an instrument, evidence that it was delivered and an assertion that it should discharge a debt do not, by themselves, establish completed payment.
Where HMRC rejects an alternative method, a business should:
- Obtain a clear explanation of HMRC’s position.
- Identify the outstanding tax and any additional amounts.
- Review the legal basis of the proposed arrangement.
- Obtain independent specialist advice where appropriate.
- Arrange an accepted method of payment or discuss an affordable payment plan.
- Consider any available legal challenge without missing relevant deadlines.
The objective should be to resolve the actual tax position, rather than rely on assumptions about the effect of documents.
For further guidance, see HMRC’s warning about bills of exchange arrangements.
What Happens if You Ignore an Outstanding HMRC Tax Debt?
Ignoring an unresolved liability can increase the financial and legal consequences.
HMRC may contact the taxpayer to seek payment or discuss an arrangement.
Where the debt remains unpaid and no acceptable resolution is reached, HMRC has statutory recovery powers.
Depending on the circumstances, enforcement action may include debt collection, court proceedings, recovery from assets or insolvency-related action.
For companies, serious unresolved tax debts can ultimately lead to winding-up proceedings.
These outcomes are not inevitable, and the appropriate action depends on the facts.
However, failing to respond can reduce the opportunities to resolve the matter before enforcement progresses.
HMRC’s guidance on unpaid tax debts explains its approach to debt recovery and the importance of early engagement.
A Practical HMRC Payment Dispute Checklist
If HMRC says your tax remains unpaid, work through the following checklist.
- Identify the tax, accounting period and amount in dispute.
- Check whether HMRC has issued a formal decision or assessment.
- Review bank transactions and payment confirmations.
- Verify the payment reference and destination.
- Check the relevant HMRC tax account.
- Contact the appropriate HMRC department.
- Ask for clarification of any remaining balance.
- Establish whether interest or penalties apply.
- Consider Time to Pay if the amount is owed but unaffordable.
- Check statutory review and appeal deadlines where relevant.
- Obtain specialist advice if the legal position is disputed.
- Retain written records of the steps taken.
A systematic approach can help resolve administrative errors and identify legal disputes before they become more difficult to manage.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I do if HMRC says my payment has not arrived?
Check the transaction with your bank, confirm the payment reference and allow for the relevant processing time. If the payment was completed but has not been allocated correctly, contact HMRC with the transaction details.
Can HMRC reject a payment method?
Yes. HMRC publishes accepted payment methods for each tax. It is not required to treat every proposed document or financial instrument as payment.
What if I used the wrong Corporation Tax reference?
Your payment may be delayed or allocated to another liability. HMRC provides a process for requesting that the payment be moved.
Can I arrange instalments if I cannot pay my tax bill?
Potentially. HMRC may agree to a Time to Pay arrangement after assessing your financial circumstances and repayment proposal.
Can I appeal because HMRC refuses to recognise my payment?
The available procedure depends on the nature of the disagreement. An administrative payment allocation issue is different from a formal appealable tax decision.
How long do I have to appeal an HMRC decision?
For many decisions, the deadline is usually 30 days, but the relevant letter and statutory rules should be checked.
Does an appeal automatically stop interest?
No. Interest may continue to accrue on tax ultimately found to be payable, even where payment is postponed during a dispute.
Can HMRC take enforcement action while a dispute is ongoing?
The position depends on the type of tax, the decision and any applicable postponement or collection restrictions. A taxpayer should not assume that correspondence or an appeal automatically prevents all recovery action.
Conclusion: Resolve the Tax Position, Not Just the Correspondence
When HMRC rejects a tax payment or proposed arrangement, the most important step is to establish why.
A processing error may require a payment trace.
An incorrect reference may require reallocation.
Financial difficulty may require an affordable payment arrangement.
A formal disagreement about tax liability may require a statutory appeal or review.
And where HMRC does not accept a proposed method of settlement, the taxpayer must determine whether the debt remains outstanding and what legally effective steps are available.
Clear records, timely communication and an understanding of the relevant procedures can help businesses protect their position and resolve disputes more effectively.